Best Hotels near Evangelical Lutheran Church of the Redeemer, New York

Stayed for a few days, looking for parking, something comfortable and affordable, and in proximity to the LIRR. Overall, it was a good stay. Our room was clean and comfortable, wifi worked well although not perfectly. The only suggestions I have would be to up the level of customer service a notch. Check-in went well and the man behind the desk was polite and competent. Some of the cleaning staff asked us whether we wanted our room cleaned. We said yes, and they did a nice job. Another person told us that service was not included and our room was not cleaned that day. Not sure what was going on, but except for that day, our room was cleaned nicely with fresh towels. The other suggestion would be to not show Fox News in the lobby. Not sure if that was for the staff or guests. If the latter, please consider programming that would be appreciated by more of your guests. No TV at all, would have been fine for me and I assume many others too.

The floor in the bathroom was wet after taking shower. Highly likely the water pipes under the pergo floor was leaking. The hotel did not replenish bottle of drinking water on the 2nd day even after I called the front desk and asked for 2 bottles.

The place is convenient to the airport and transportation is easy and the staff on duty are accommodating of your request. They also have free ride to the hotel or if your flight is early, they will find a ride for you. :)

Was unable to get early check in even though requested a few months back when initially booked. But that’s ok, they had a convenient luggage hold. And checkin at the ready time was very smooth! Biggest issue with this specific location, they have over 40 floors of rooms and only 2 elevators. It took forever to catch one anytime coming back to the room.

as expected, the pod room is compact and clean. the shower is great. having the toilet in it is odd. ok for a solo traveler but not ideal for a couple. air con worked well. wifi was good tho not super fast. the location is fantastic, very close to great shops and cafes etc. having a good sized safe under the bed is great to store valuables. the bed is big and comfy - tho it was very easy to bash your leg against the edge of the frame, which i did three times within a day before hanging a towel over it to avoid further leg scuffs! only four hangers in the room but another four delivered swiftly when requested. having a mini fridge in the room would have been welcome.

The hotel is more like a hostel. Very small rooms small double bed or bunk beds because you will not fit two single beds in the room. Shower very good. No tea or coffee making facilities in the room. Yes tv. No breakfast included. You have to go to a nearby cafe to get a proper meal. You can get various coffee and tea bagels scones continental style breakfast in the bar area in the POD. For 4 nights accommodation only Thursday to Sunday cost app 1200.00 euro per room.

I stayed here for ten consecutive days. The location of the hotel is very convenient for traveling. The path is just 100 meters outside the hotel. The fitness and breakfast facilities are comprehensive. The service level is acceptable. It is recommended for people traveling or staying for a short stay. The coffee was very delicious, which was an unexpected surprise.

Pros - Location was great on W39th between 8th & 9th so very central and near lots of bars and restaurants in Times Square. We were able to walk everywhere from our hotel, including Central Park, which is approx 30 min walk. - We found the bed very comfy and enjoyed having the fridge to keep our water cold during the day - The staff were friendly and helpful with booking a car to bring us to the airport and we were welcomed warmly to the hotel. The cleaning staff were also extremely friendly and always smiling, which is always a good sign in my opinion. Cons - Our bedroom door was very stiff to the extent that we thought we were locked in and stuck in the room after the first night and needed to call reception to help us out. The door would be a bit of a safety hazard if there was an emergency and the engineer who helped us did not seem too concerned with the reported issue. - The breakfast was very busy and difficult to get a table to sit at. There was a good choice with bagels / cooked food / yoghurt / cereals and tea / coffee but the food itself was cheap and we decided not to avail of it after the first morning. Coffee was good though! - The floor in our room wasn’t very clean and was sticky even after cleaning. Our socks were filthy if we didn’t wear shoes around the room. - The room was expensive but in-line with New York prices. We chose this as a slightly more expensive hotel due to the breakfast included but we didn’t end up availing of the breakfast due to it not meeting our expectations, which was a bit disappointing.

Hotel was amazing, the front desk workers and managers were very nice! They gave us wonderful advice and directions around the city! Hotel is located in a very convenient spot every is walking distance.

It was pretty easy to book, find, and to get into the hotel. The front desk person has the room keys ready, so we got to the room in a few seconds. It was clean and quite even the room was located next to the elevator. Me and my friends have relaxed time there.