Looking for hotels near Coney Island Beach & Boardwalk? Take inspiration from real travellers.

Top rated hotels in New York

Searching for hotels near Coney Island Beach & Boardwalk? Compare room rates and reviews to find your ideal stay.
Insignia Hotel, Ascend Hotel Collection
4/5133 Reviews
Stayed in Insignia as renovations were being done in my apartment near by. Its a small hotel with 5 floors and 87 rooms, king rooms face the front and queen face the back. My room was on the 5th floor facing the back and looking down on the limited space parking lot. You must request a refrigerator as they are based on availability. There isn't much space around the Queen bed so it makes it tight. There is no iron or ironing board if you do need one in the room. The customer service definitely is different with who is at the front desk. I only have dealt with an Asian man who is very helpful, kind and greets you everytime. My husband dealt with a women who was rude. Parking as mentioned is in a limited space parking lot and is $29 a night. It does have in and our privileges but you can definitely find a spot on the block. I would recommend this hotel for a very short stay like a night or two just because the type of guest here can give it a bad name. Smoking is not permitted, however you smell **** throughout the floors. Only plus is that it is a updated hotel which was built in 2018 so you have the LCD TV on the wall mount and a nicely built bathroom with Shampoo, Conditioner and Body Wash in the shower already with a pump to be used.
Holiday Inn Express - NYC Brooklyn - Sunset Park, an IHG Hotel
4.2/5113 Reviews
The room is nice, the breakfast is very good, there is a slight subway noise, which I can accept. It is very convenient to take the subway line D to Manhattan. It is also close to Eighth Avenue. There are Chinese restaurants within a few steps. I will stay here next time. I booked it on Ctrip Regarding the room, Ctrip was also very responsible and arranged everything accordingly.
The L Hotel
3.8/5121 Reviews
Everything is fine. The location is convenient, 20 minutes by subway to Manhattan, an hour from the airport by public transport. The internet was bad. Not very clean rooms.
Best Western Brooklyn-Coney Island Inn
4.2/5106 Reviews
We were looking to spend a few days at Coney Island. The hotel was one of the closest, but still a 15-20 minute walk away, which is not particularly close. You have to walk by a busy cement yard and numerous auto repair shops to get there. Despite the walk, we were able to visit all the area sites without any problems. The hotel was clean and the staff were friendly. There were a variety of items for breakfast and the woman worked very hard to keep the food stocked during the morning rush. All in all, we had a good stay and it was worth the price.
Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay Hotel
3.7/5102 Reviews
Our group stay at Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay last week was very pleasant. The service was outstanding on all stages - from booking the rooms with Reema, the group sales manager (very professional, prompt and accommodating), to the front desk assistance and hotel staff. The location is perfect (a very picturesque neighborhood, beautiful Sheepshead Bay canal across the road, wonderful restaurants and shops), the rooms are big and clean. We have already booked our next stay in March and we hope to be returning to this hotel again and again. Highly recommended!
Avid Hotel Brooklyn - Dyker Heights
4.4/558 Reviews
The facilities were really nice. The staff are also very friendly, I was really impressed by the free breakfast and fitness center. Next time I come to New York, I want to come again.

Frequently Asked Questions