Cliff Lodge

Overall we were pleased with our stay. We came from mainland to enjoy the island without the overflow of tourism. As a New Englander I really want to make something clear based on prior reviews for those that come from Midwest or West or even the south: New England is old. If you are expecting modern amenities in a 1775 house, you might be reaching a bit. Older New england bnbs and hotels can only do so much in terms of updates. As the owner of a property from the 1700s, I understand firsthand the upkeep and expenses associated with keeping up the historical charm. Although there's only so much one can do with updates on older buildings like these, the cliff lodge can use some TLC here and there but I would expect any updates to be in April when tourist season resumes and they've had winter to do any updates. Rooms: We were in a smaller, albeit quaint room #10. We loved the lookout right next to us (deck) and appreciated having a private bath (note that some bnbs on top floors have shared baths). Beds were surprisingly comfy and staff turned down daily which was a nice surprise. Breakfast: I say this is more of a breakfast of convenience rather than a traditional bnb so do keep that in mind. Mostly bagels, pastries, coffee, oats. Juice---basics. Not a problem with me but some may want a full kitchen experience.

We got put in room 3 which I think is their smallest. The bed takes up most of the room. It had a small AC unit. We were told not to use the ceiling fan because it makes too much noise in room above. Walls do not block noisy phone call from room across hall. Creaky floors. Bathroom so small that at 6'4" I had to sit diagonal on the toilet so knees wouldn't hit wall in front. Shower stall extremely small about 2'x2'. There is a phone number to call if you want to speak to staff. No one around for average breakfast buffet with what tastes like day old coffee. Everything looks a bit "tired". Back door broken, etc.. For us it was premium price with budget value. We complained to owner asking for price reduction but got nowhere. They did suggest that the room could be had for slightly cheaper price if booked directly. Our expectations were for a nice bed and breakfast experience like we have in Michigan. We were disappointed.

It was the off season but the hotel was still wonderful and quiet! Within walking distance of town. No car needed unless you want to venture out of town

Authentic accommodation with kind, helpful staff. Quite comfortable and close to everything. There is no elevator and the stairs are steep. Our room was clean and comfortable. We felt safe and slept well. Continental breakfast provided

This is not a B & B experience. We were given a key and gave it back when we left. Housecleaning was perfect but breakfast was with a gallon of juice that you could get from the refrigerator. You eat and leave dishes on a sideboard . If help was needed you had to telephone. No one on site either day or night.

There is absolutely no air conditioning so on hot days you have no relief from the heat coming back to the room at the hotel. I got a headache and lethargic. There is also no heat and during my stay it was also very windy dropping under 50 degrees. I’ve never been so cold for a room I’m paying over $500 per night! I would not recommend staying here if either of those things are important to you. The location is convenient and the place is clean but that’s all I’d say is positive.