The Edgartown Inn, the Edgartown Collection

I would 100% recommend this as a place to stay in Edgartown. The location on Water Street is great, the rooms nice (cosy!) and the staff are fab! We were lucky to be there for 4th July and the parade came right past the property! There isn’t a restaurant or bar but Edgartown is lovely with lots of great places to eat or get coffee / ice cream within easy walking distance. You can also bring drinks back to the hotel and enjoy them by the fire pit in the evening. Absolutely fab trip and would definitely stay here again. Thank you Edgartown Inn!!

The service and staff are really great, no problem there. IMO, I felt like I was staying in a Holoday In Express. it just had that kind of vibe. Especially the breakfast common area, you know the ones where everybody is standing around going thru a free continental breakfast? Unfortunately there is nothing unique and special about it. The walls are so thin you can hear people in the halls slamming doors and people walking around in the rooms above. No robes, nothing upscale about this place at all. It was just blah! For $600 a night I expect more.Glad I just stayed one night.

The Edgartown Inn far exceeded our expectations in every sense. We would definitely stay there again. They have free parking, although, our rental car stayed in the lot most of the time, as shops and restaurants are all very walkable. The Edgartown Inn is a great value, and even though breakfast is not included, you'll find that the Inn's $10 breakfast is well worth it. It's also just a 3 minute walk to the picturesque lighthouse down the very same street. Grab a book from the library right next door, and sit on their lovely porch for a view to the water.

We had booked here as been wanted to visit the area for years and linked it in with a trip to Boston. Nice drive to catch the ferry and a smooth crossing. Easy drive to the hotel and we arrived early which wasn’t a problem given the time of year but would guess it would have been in high season. Checked in and shown to our room and treated to warm chocolate cookies what a start. Asked for recommendations for places to eat and visit, shown on a detailed map where to eat and even places to visit further afield which we did as beautiful scenery around the island. Rooms are very clean and superbly decorated and presented, it made a change to have a proper shower rather than where we had stayed previous along with some lovely bath products. Simple breakfast but sufficient and some nice touches with different options to eat and teas to drink. Overall a great place to stay and would recommend. One gripe was the cost of parking given the price being paid for the room, and having just seen on trip advisor it’s being promoted as FREE PARKING which is not the case it’s $50 a night additional fees.

Staying at the Edgartown Inn feels like coming home. The staff are warm and professional, and do everything they can to make your stay enjoyable. While the old decor of the Inn was full of history and antiques, the new renovations are well-done and provide a peaceful and cozy update to this historic gem of an inn. The rooms are comfortable, the breakfast is delicious, and the warm chocolate chip cookies are not to be missed! We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and highly recommend this inn for visitors to Martha's Vineyard.

Very nice hotel, centrally located in Edgartown. Nothing seemed to be more than a 5 minute walk away. Neusa and her team kept everything pristine! Rooms are a bit small, but well appointed and there's a lot of common space to relax in. We really appreciated the beach chairs and towels that were available. Would definitely return!